linkedinbloggertumblr
facebooktwitterreddit

Humanism Versus Mystrikism

1. Introduction

Citation Information

Allan, Leslie 2025. Humanism Versus Mystrikism, URL = <https://www.rationalrealm.com/philosophy/metaphysics/humanism-versus-mystrikism.html>.

Woman holding light string in silhouette

Mystrikism is a philosophy of life much akin to the humanist philosophy. Duncan McDonald is the originator and puts his philosophy like this:

Mystrikism is a sensible, syncretic, philosophical identity offering a naturalistic alternative to traditional religion. We uphold an ethos that prioritises kindness and honesty through compassion and the methods of science without relying on unsubstantiated ideas such as the supernatural.

[McDonald 2023]

No humanist would disagree with this approach. Nonetheless, McDonald thinks humanism requires an upgrade. As he puts it: 'Mystrikism respectfully enhances, complements, and expands upon the scope of humanism' [McDonald 2023].

The problem McDonald [2024] has with humanism is on five fronts, as follows:

First, it has a 'Human-Centric Focus': 'Humanism's emphasis on human welfare and potential is often seen as anthropocentric, which centres humans as the most essential life forms in the universe.'

Second, it does not pay sufficient heed to 'Earth's Ecological Balance': 'Mystrikism criticises humanism for failing to recognise the interconnectedness of all life forms. Decisions primarily focusing on environmental issues that benefit humanity can lead to ecological imbalances and environmental degradation.'

Third, it largely ignores 'Non-Human Perspectives': 'Mystriks argue that humanism does not adequately consider the intrinsic value of non-human life forms. Animals, plants, and entire ecosystems are often viewed through the lens of their utility to humans rather than their inherent worth.'

Fourth, it fails to take a 'Cosmic Perspective': 'From a cosmological standpoint, the human-centric view is seen as limited and narrow. Earth is not the centre of the universe, and humans are not the pinnacle of life.'

Fifth, it is prone to 'Neglecting "Spirituality" & Meaning': 'Humanism is sometimes seen as insufficient in addressing existential questions about the meaning and purpose of life. Humanism centres on human progress and fulfilment, which leads to a neglect of a deeper search for relevance and significance.'

I can understand McDonald wanting to differentiate his new philosophy from others that have come before it. However, is what he writes about humanism true? In this essay, I'll take a deep dive into the reasons he gives for his demoting of the humanist outlook. (Well-known Sentientist, Jamie Woodhouse, similarly faults humanism for being human-centric. I respond to Woodhouse's criticisms in Humanism Versus Sentientism [Allan 2025].)

The core of McDonald's assessment is given in his essay titled Humanism - A Friendly Critique [McDonald 2024]. (All references in this essay are to McDonald [2024] unless otherwise noted.) In it, he tells us he 'critically examines various key humanist texts' to show us 'where humanism may fall short in recognising the needs of other sapient beings (as yet undiscovered), sentient life, the environment, and nature’s ecosystems'. His critique enumerates these four areas of concern in particular:

  1. Human-Centric Focus
  2. Subduing Hubris and Egotism
  3. Ethics and Morality Beyond Humans
  4. Naturalised "Spirituality"

In Section 2, I review in turn each of his criticisms of the key Humanist documents he identifies. In Section 3, I explore in more depth how an insufficient attention to the history of humanism and the meaning of the term can easily lead to the misunderstanding that humanism is anthropocentric. In Section 4, I place humanists' concerns for animal rights and environmental degradation within the broader context of humanist priorities and objectives. Finally, I wrap up with some concluding thoughts on comparisons between humanism and Mystrikism.

Note that for clarity, where I refer to humanism as a philosophy of life or world view, I will use the lowercase 'h'. Where I refer to the Humanist movement consisting of organizations, leaders and members, I will use the uppercase 'H'. The only exceptions will be where either word is part of a quotation.

Copyright © 2025

You will be interested in
Humanism: A Very Short Introduction
The Little Book of Humanism: Universal lessons on finding purpose, meaning and joy
Humanism: A Beginner's Guide
Renaissance Humanism: An Anthology of Sources
Misquoting Jesus: The Story Behind Who Changed the Bible and Why
Enlightenment Thought: An Anthology of Sources

Share This

  • twitter
  • facebook
  • linkedin
  • googleplus
  • gmail
  • delicious
  • reddit
  • digg
  • newsvine
  • posterous
  • friendfeed
  • googlebookmarks
  • yahoobookmarks
  • yahoobuzz
  • orkut
  • stumbleupon
  • diigo
  • mixx
  • technorati
  • netvibes
  • myspace
  • slashdot
  • blogger
  • tumblr
  • email
Short URL: